Breathalyzer and Blood Tests: Assessing Reliability and Challenging Accuracy in Florida Courts

Back to DUI / DUI Arrest Blog

Breathalyzer and Blood Tests: Assessing Reliability and Challenging Accuracy in Florida Courts

man opening beer bottle while driving

Breathalyzer and blood tests are commonly used by law enforcement to measure a driver’s blood alcohol content (BAC) in DUI cases. These tests are crucial pieces of evidence that can significantly impact the outcome of a DUI trial. However, they are not infallible and can be subject to various factors that may affect their accuracy. In this blog post, we will explore the reliability of breathalyzer and blood tests and the potential avenues for challenging their accuracy in Florida courts.

Reliability of Breathalyzer Tests

Breathalyzer tests are portable devices used to estimate a person’s BAC by measuring the amount of alcohol in their breath. While these tests can be useful in assessing whether a driver is over the legal BAC limit, they are not without limitations.

  • Calibration and Maintenance: Breathalyzers require regular calibration and maintenance to ensure accurate results. If not properly calibrated or maintained, the test results may be skewed, leading to false readings.
  • Environmental Factors: External factors, such as residual mouth alcohol, certain medications, or substances present in the environment (like paint fumes or gasoline), can impact breathalyzer readings.
  • Individual Differences: Breathalyzer tests assume a standardized alcohol-to-breath ratio, but individual differences can affect the accuracy of the results. Factors like lung capacity, body temperature, and breathing patterns can influence the BAC reading.

Reliability of Blood Tests

Blood tests, on the other hand, are considered more accurate in determining a person’s BAC level. They directly measure the alcohol content in the bloodstream. However, blood tests are not immune to potential errors or challenges.

  • Sample Contamination: Mishandling of blood samples or contamination can lead to inaccurate results. Proper collection, storage, and transportation procedures are essential to maintain the integrity of the sample.
  • Laboratory Errors: Blood tests are typically analyzed in laboratories, and errors can occur during the testing process. Quality control measures must be followed to minimize the risk of inaccurate results.

Challenging the Accuracy of Tests in Court

When facing DUI charges in Florida based on breathalyzer or blood test results, individuals have the right to challenge the accuracy of the tests. Skilled DUI defense attorneys may explore various avenues to challenge the reliability of these tests in court:

  • Officer Training and Administration: Attorneys may question the training and experience of the officer administering the tests. If the officer did not follow proper procedures or lacked the necessary training, it could impact the validity of the results.
  • Calibration and Maintenance Records: Attorneys may request the calibration and maintenance records of the breathalyzer device used in the case. Discrepancies or irregularities in these records can be used to challenge the accuracy of the test results.
  • External Factors: Attorneys may investigate whether external factors, such as medications, medical conditions, or environmental substances, could have influenced the breathalyzer results.
  • Independent Testing: In some cases, the defense may conduct an independent BAC test using a different device or method to compare the results and determine the accuracy of the initial test.
  • Blood Sample Analysis: If a blood test was conducted, the defense may request access to the blood sample for independent analysis to assess its integrity and accuracy.


Breathalyzer and blood tests are significant pieces of evidence in DUI cases in Florida. While they can provide valuable information about a driver’s BAC level, they are not without limitations and can be challenged in court. An experienced DUI defense attorney can carefully examine the administration and accuracy of these tests to ensure their client’s rights are protected. If you are facing DUI charges based on breathalyzer or blood test results, it is crucial to seek legal representation promptly to explore potential challenges and build a strong defense strategy. Remember, everyone has the right to challenge evidence presented against them in court and seek a fair legal process.

Share this post

Back to DUI / DUI Arrest Blog